Elden Ring's Shadow of the Erdtree DLC: A Double-Edged Sword of Difficulty and Praise

Despite critical acclaim and a high Metacritic score pre-launch, Elden Ring's Shadow of the Erdtree DLC has received a mixed reception on Steam, with players voicing concerns about difficulty and performance. While lauded for its challenging gameplay, many Steam reviews express frustration with excessively difficult combat encounters, questionable enemy placement and boss health scaling, and widespread performance issues across PC and consoles.

Related Video: Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree - Subverted Expectations

The DLC's demanding battles are a major point of contention. Players describe fights as significantly harder than the base game, with some feeling the difficulty is disproportionate and poorly balanced. Criticisms include "rushed" enemy placement and bosses possessing excessively large health pools.

Performance problems further compound the negative feedback. PC users report frequent crashes, micro-stuttering, and frame rate limitations, even on high-end systems. Frame rates below 30 FPS in crowded areas render the game unplayable for some. PlayStation users report similar frame rate drops during intense gameplay sequences.

As of Monday, Steam shows a "Mixed" overall review for Shadow of the Erdtree, with 36% negative reviews. Metacritic currently rates it "Generally Favorable" (8.3/10) based on 570 user reviews, while Game8 awards it a 94/100 rating, highlighting the divergence in player and critic opinions. The discrepancy underscores the significant challenges and divisive nature of the DLC's increased difficulty and technical shortcomings.